๐Ÿ›๏ธ๐Ÿ“ž MetaGov Working Group โ€“ 2025 Meetings: Tuesdays at 2pm UTC (Currently 10:00 am ET)

1. Weekly Endowment Updates (@karpatkey + @Steakhouse )

  • Endowment at $123M, down $10M due to ETH price decline
  • Stables now 24% allocation (previously 18%)
    • 94M in ETH, $30M in stablecoins
    • Continue selling ETH to rebalance
  • APR at 2.83% (low due to LST redemptions)
  • Weekly commentary:
  • Portfolio rebalancing progress:
    • Sold 1.6k ETH at ~$3.7k each for $6.12M USDC
    • Deployed in Compound and Aave
    • Shifted 10% USDS into Aave (5% APY)

2. General DAO Updates Section

2.1 OpenBox Proposal Committee Update

  • The committee sent Josh and his team a number of questions based on their own queries and submissions by DAO participants.
  • Currently awaiting a response to the latest questions and will be able to give a more detailed update soon.

3. Delegate Open Discussion

Token Treasury and Usage (proposal)

  • ENS has one of the largest treasuries owned and controlled by the DAO.
  • Unlike other ecosystems, ENS hasnโ€™t used its tokens for public-facing partnerships, deals, or security mechanisms.
  • The DAO is now at a reasonable stance and market cap to consider distributing more responsibility and empowering communities and partnerships.
  • The proposal aims to explore nuanced experiments using tokens (a few hundred thousand to a few million dollars) to inspire the community and drive registrations.
  • The proposal will be posted on the forum in the next couple of days.
  • James wants feedback from delegates and contributors.
  • Seeking ideas for cool experiments, incentives, partnerships, or programs to run with tokens to inspire community and drive registrations.

Ideas and Suggestions

  • James from Lighthouse suggested the Signals protocol, where people put up ideas and lock their tokens, similar to conviction voting.
  • The DAO could have a prize pool of ENS tokens to distribute to community members who are the most active and participate the most.
  • The new register controller and ENSIP-19 update added a referral parameter to the events that will be emitted, allowing tracking and having referral fees for .eth registrations.
  • Ideas for incentivizing projects, such as those using onchain contracts with ENS names/subnames via ENScribe.
  • A test will be run for 500 days to see how it goes, and then report back.

Concerns, gamification, user alignment

  • ENS has two distinct communities: DAO participants and domain marketplace users, who need to be value-aligned.
  • James expressed concern that incentivizing can lead to gamification and grifting, attracting users for the wrong reasons.
  • Some people have left the ENS ecosystem because they donโ€™t consider it a welcoming or well-incentivized ecosystem to work in.
  • Thomas mentioned an airdrop of 10 ENS tokens to founders in Kenya, which led to them building on ENS.

Other

  • Thrive protocol was mentioned, which has worked with ecosystems like Polygon, Boba, Swell, and ApeCoin DAO to incentivize community members for creating real value.
  • It automates the distribution of tokens for onchain and offchain tasks
  • Proposal is up for .locker TLD transfer.

Blockful update

  • Two-part update: 1) Upgrading the Governor contract and 2) Creating incentives to improve delegation.
  • There are 353 days left on the Security Council before it becomes permissionless to be canceled.
    • Need to have better security and delegation, or a new Security Council
  • Updates to the forum regarding a governor upgrade will be available by the end of the month.
    • Focused on metrics that impact security.
    • Exploring options like optimistic governance.
  • To make governance more resilient, bigger delegation thresholds are needed.
  • Since the veto council was disabled, the treasury is above the delegated supply again, which is unsafe without the Security Council.
  • A new feature was shipped to track top delegates and their voting.
    • Allows seeing each delegateโ€™s votes, where their voting power comes from.
    • Can follow delegation changes as delegators sell, buy, or redelegate
  • Engagement improvement: Working on a Telegram notification system (with plans for Slack too)
    • Allows people to follow governance, get notified of new proposals, and track their delegates voting.
  • In the coming weeks, there will be a feature to click and see what transactions have an impact.
  • The goal is to improve defense by understanding how distributions and tech profitability are changing.
  • If someone starts buying or delegating many tokens, there will be the next steps as a preemptive measure.
  • If ETH were to 3x, the cost to attack would look aggressively bad.
  • Working on organizational charts to understand where treasuries are on different wallets and how they are composed.

Blockful links and resources:

Spending report

  • Spending report is out and you can find it here.
  • The working groups take pride in being a gold standard on transparency in the DAO space :saluting_face:

Service provider quarterly updates and accountability

  • Only 3 service providers have posted their quarterly updates on the forum.
  • Guidance is needed on the expected cadence of these reports.
  • If reports are missed twice in a row, it can cause action.
1 Like